← Blog

What is a management system?

  • Lean
  • 7 min read
  • 17 June 2024

Have you noticed that the only reason advanced and complex “things” work is because they operate as systems? Take the human body as an example: we have the respiratory system, the cardiovascular system, the immune system, and so on… On Earth, various ecosystems coexist, from forests to deserts, from mountains to cities… And even the Milky Way, the galaxy we live in, includes our solar system and many others. When these systems function in a balanced and efficient way, everything usually goes well. When they do not, problems arise.

If we draw a comparison with the reality of a company, we can find many parallels. There are countless “systems” within an organisation. In this article, however, we will discuss the so-called “management system”.

In summary, this refers to how management work is organised and how it takes place every day within the organisation. A management system encompasses the structuring of all management activities within what we might call the “business ecosystem”: communication of the strategy and objectives of the different areas, setting goals, management routines, problem-solving, feedback, performance evaluations, and so on. In short, all management-related processes connected to the different levels of the organisation fall under the management system.

If we once again draw an analogy with a living organism, something many thinkers have done, then the management system would be the skeleton that provides support and structure to the organs and vital tissues.

A first, very important realisation is that it is impossible not to have some kind of management system in operation. It is always there, although not always as efficiently as we would like: indeed, if a company is functioning, a management system inevitably already exists, even if it may be hidden in plain sight. Perhaps this is the first major challenge: seeing it.

If we cannot “see” our management system, we will never be able to identify the gaps and improve it. Why? Because if the management system has not been carefully and consciously conceived, designed and organised, it will be no more than a random collection of disconnected individual practices that will cause a great deal of harm.

We see this happening every day in companies. One example is when important decisions are made too late and reactively, as a result of poor communication and a lack of transparency about actual performance. The combination of incorrect, insufficient information and decision-making that takes place “in the heat of the moment”, driven primarily by the personal views of those in power, is incredibly dangerous.

Another example is when problems are “solved” by the wrong hierarchical levels, using unsuitable means and inappropriate people. Or when the “vacuum” created by the lack of scalable and well-designed communication processes is immediately filled by the “grapevine”, coffee conversations that turn rumours into absolute truths.

There are indeed various disruptions caused by the absence of a good management system. Being unaware of this may well be the most fundamental cause of many of the problems and instabilities experienced by companies and their leadership teams, such as information and communication failing to flow, problems being identified too late, customers being affected and then drifting away, and poor results that can no longer be reversed.

In a company with a poorly designed and inefficient management system, people often feel lost. They struggle to understand the real purpose of their roles and how they will be evaluated. At best, they work according to bureaucracy. And leaders spend most of their time putting out fires or planning meetings with other managers who are equally overloaded.

Even worse is the common problem of “personalisation”: when a leader takes over a department or even the entire company and then redesigns the system to suit their own preferences, introducing new routines, indicators and forms of evaluation without following scientific or technical criteria. By doing so, they may even set aside years of experience and knowledge accumulated by managers who previously held that position.

When this happens, management starts to generate noise, create useless work and distribute unnecessary or contradictory information, causing confusion at the frontline, when it should instead be supporting value-creating processes. This usually causes the company to become rigid, sometimes even paralysed. In turn, this encourages people to collect dubious data and hold unproductive meetings, while value-creating work flows randomly and problems are solved impulsively and inefficiently.

With every new change, more and more psychological uncertainty, wear and tear, setbacks and loss are generated: meeting formats are changed, reports are exchanged, indicators are “recycled” and evaluations are carried out again, but problems remain and grow.

This is a complex subject that requires much more thought. The purpose of this brief is not to exhaust the subject, but to generate some considerations. Below, we list what we consider to be the fundamental elements of an efficient management system from the Lean perspective.

A Lean management system must connect the entire company, both in macro and micro dimensions, across different hierarchical levels, in different functional areas and processes, all the way down to the individual. It must be focused on continuously bringing problems to light, preferably as soon as they arise, interrupting poor processes so that they can be reconsidered and improved, with the support of higher hierarchical levels where necessary. To achieve this, a management system must promote and facilitate scientific thinking.

It must be based on management standards that help keep processes and frontline work stable, while at the same time exposing problems so that they can be continuously improved. It must be based on simple, educational and easy-to-understand visual management that monitors critical indicators and shows the expected versus the actual condition, in order to promote transparency about the process and performance. It must also actively encourage respect for people and promote psychological safety, so that everyone can flag problems and improve their daily work to the best of their ability and within the scope of their authority.

Well-designed management systems optimise everyone’s time within the organisation. They create daily opportunities for horizontal and vertical alignment. They make space for constructive interactions with the team at the Gemba, supporting people development and the evolution of processes. They ensure communication and the flow of the right information, at the right time, to the right people, so that problems can be found and solved as quickly as possible.

In summary, from a Lean perspective, a management system must be designed so that the company can continuously evolve and performance can reach new levels. For this to happen, you cannot depend on the “manager of the moment”: the organisation of management work must be carefully considered and structured, so that the living organism that is the company can lead a healthy, long and prosperous life.

Would you like to build a working system with your team for daily management, problem solving and sustaining results on the shop floor? You do that in nine weeks with the Lean Wave Programme. Would you like to know first where you stand? Then request the Maturity Scan.


Authors

__wf_reserved_inherit
Flávio Battaglia is President of Lean Institute Brasil
__wf_reserved_inherit
Luciana Gomes is Project Manager and Head of Banking and Retail at Lean Institute Brasil.

Gerelateerde blogs