Koninklijke Vezet – Kaizen Event
- Koninklijke Vezet
Client
Koninklijke Vezet
Industry
Food and Agro
Result
60 heads per minute, up from 40
Trainer
Riegholt Hilbrands
Trainer / adviseur
Curious about what we can do for your organisation?
Get in touchWhat was the issue from the customer's perspective?
Endive is available at Albert Heijn all year round, in three packs: 250 grams finely chopped, 400 grams and 500 grams finely chopped. Vezet produces all three.
Two things were under pressure. The cost price, which made the product more expensive in store than comparable endive elsewhere. And freshness. Endive that is limp and damp on the shelf towards the end of its shelf life is written off, and this happened often enough to stand out.
The second issue could be expressed in financial terms, and that is what gave direction to the week. In 2021, more than half a million euros' worth of endive was written off. The team calculated one ratio that guided everything: extending the shelf life by one day reduces those write-offs by approximately 15 per cent, or around 82,000 euros per year.
“Of all the time a head of endive spends in the process, 0.14 per cent is value-adding: removing the core and cutting, cleaning and packing. The rest is waiting, moving and storing.”
This gave the improvement week a measurable objective: extend the sales window in store by at least one day.
How did the work need to be improved?
First, the team mapped the value stream, from receipt of the heads to the finished product in cold storage.
This produced one figure that changed the conversation. Of all the time a head of endive spends in the process, 0.14 per cent is value-adding: removing the core and cutting, cleaning and packing. The rest is waiting, moving and storing.
The map also showed where that waiting occurs. Raw materials wait for zero to three days before being processed, and not in order of arrival, so a three-day-old head can enter the line before a fresh one. The production process itself, from loading the head to the packing table, takes six minutes and twenty seconds.
The team then determined the takt time using a full year of order data, from week 47 of 2021 to week 46 of 2022. Five scenarios were compared, ranging from the busiest promotional day ever to the average of all production days. They selected 1.36 seconds per consumer unit, the pace the line had demonstrably achieved at its best. At that pace, 39,600 units fit into one day, compared with the 29,043 units used in planning at the time.
With the current situation and desired pace side by side, four bottlenecks remained: loading, packing, the lift and the sales window in store.
What knowledge and skills were needed?
Value stream analysis in three steps.
First map the current state, then design an ideal state in three small groups, and only then define a future state that takes a step in that direction. This prevents a team from improving the existing line by a few per cent while leaving the real question unanswered.
Takt time based on customer demand.
The pace is based on what the customer demands, not on what the machine can handle, calculated using a year of actual orders and broken down across the three packs.
Measuring cycle times on the shop floor.
Positioning a crate: 8.7 seconds per batch of 8.6 kilos. Loading heads: 27 seconds per batch, 0.75 seconds per unit. Packing: 0.98 seconds per unit without interruptions and 1.23 seconds with interruptions. The difference between those last two figures is exactly what the packing bottleneck is about.
Standardised work as the outcome.
Fixed recipes for each product in the system, work instructions for loading and agreements on rotating employees.
Having the operators take the measurements themselves.
Data was missing for the packing bottleneck, because the system records film changes and metal checks, but not the occasions when an employee stops the packaging machine. The team therefore created a form with three columns: item, duration and reason. Above these was a request for the operator to help, and below was the sender: the Endive Kaizen team.
A tree diagram for the sales window.
To work backwards from the objective (fewer write-offs) to what needed to change in planning to achieve it.
How were people involved in the improvement?
The measurements were divided among pairs from the team: takt time, cycle time for loading and packing, machine capacity, infeed and outfeed, and the flow of information. Each pair included someone who does the work and someone who knows the figures.
This is also reflected in the action plan. Each action has a primary owner and someone providing support, and those names come from the line: team leaders, engineers, the supervisor, planning and sales. The first action on the list is not an analysis but a walk along the loading line with the supervisor, engineer and team leader to see what is possible.
The form for the operators follows the same principle. It asked for knowledge that only exists on the shop floor, and asked for it in a way that clearly explained its purpose.
What leadership system is needed to sustain this?
A 30-60-90 action plan. For each action, a pillar, an owner and three columns: what will be completed after 30, 60 and 90 days. Mark it green when it is complete.
A progress meeting every two weeks, recorded as an action with an owner.
Status updates in the plan itself. On 26 January and 9 February 2023, the status of each action was added. This covered not only what had been completed, but also what had been dropped and why. For example, one test was stopped because it became clear that the reader could not be omitted for two of the three suppliers.
An explicit assessment of priorities. The longer term was included in the A3 as future state 2, with an air dryer and a vision system. That investment was first allocated to another product because the business case was stronger there. This decision and its reason were documented in the plan.
Taking the A3 to the management board. Completing and presenting it was listed as an action, with an owner and a date.
Result
Within three months of the improvement week, the action plan showed what had changed for each topic.
At loading, the maximum speed was increased from 40 to 60 heads per minute because the weighing conveyor downstream of the corer now automatically adjusts the speed of the infeed conveyor. This immediately prompted the follow-up question appropriate to such an intervention: is adjusting every two minutes too reactive, and are 45 heads per minute enough to keep variation low?
For the lift and centrifuge, the control method was changed from volume to time, with both set to 39 seconds. As a result, they are no longer bottlenecks.
There is a fixed recipe for each product in the corer's system: 747 kilos per hour for the 250-gram pack, 1,136 for the 400-gram pack and 1,345 for the 500-gram pack, accompanied by an instruction.
In planning, the line is no longer fully scheduled with unnecessary pre-production, and pre-production is no longer scaled up without reason in the daily schedules. A production wheel based on actual production in 2022 is in place, and the daily safety stock has been adjusted.
In packing, a test on an alternative line showed that an experienced packing operator can keep up with 44 cycles per minute.
What does this mean for your organisation?
With fresh products, the money is in the hours. One extra day of shelf life changes the write-offs, and that day is gained in the preceding process: how long the raw material waits, the order in which it is processed and whether the line follows the customer's pace.
A Kaizen week makes that calculation visible and assigns owners to it. View the Kaizen events →
Facing a similar challenge in
your organisation?
We help organisations achieve sustainable change, from strategy to the shop floor. Get in touch to discover what we can do for you.
Where does your organisation stand with Lean?
Over one to three days, depending on the scope, experienced consultants assess your organisation across 30 dimensions through interviews and observations on the shop floor. You receive a report with scores and priorities.